Supreme Court gun case would ‘open the floodgates’ to violence in NYC

The US Supreme Court will “open the floodgates” to more violence in the Big Apple if it overturns a law that puts limits on carrying a concealed gun in public, NYPD Police Commissioner Dermot Shea warned Sunday.

The top cop spoke out about the closely watched case being considered by the nation’s highest court — which signaled last week that it may side with gun advocates who want to expand the ability to legally carry concealed weapons in New York.

“What is being argued is that any attempt to regulate by our license division in New York City should be struck down,” Shea said on WABC’s “The Cats Roundtable” radio show.

“That would really open the floodgates in terms of people being able to carry guns across the city.”

He continued on the WABC radio show, “Gun violence is something that certainly has hit us in the last two years –and not just New York but across the country — and we would argue the last thing we need is the infusion of additional guns into the streets of New York City.”

According to NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea, the Supreme Court will "open the flood gates" to more violence if they overturn a law that puts limits on carrying a concealed gun in public.
According to NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea, the Supreme Court will “open the flood gates” to more violence if they overturn a law that puts limits on carrying a concealed gun in public.
AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana
Dermot Shea also railed against reducing jail populations through bail reform and suggested courts and lawmakers were consistently making cops’ jobs harder.
Dermot Shea also railed against reducing jail populations through bail reform and suggested courts and lawmakers were consistently making cops’ jobs harder.
Paul Martinka

Robert Nash and Brandon Koch, gun owners in Upstate New York, argue that their Second Amendment rights were violated by being denied concealed carry permits. They could not demonstrate a special need for protection.

But Shea doesn’t want to see more armed New Yorkers taking the law into their own hands.

“You’ll hear people that would love the right to carry a gun, but from our viewpoint it’s a tough enough environment as it is,” he said.

Commissioner Dermot Shea cited recent cases of innocent bystanders hit by stray bullets as examples of why guns should be controlled.
Commissioner Dermot Shea spoke out about recent cases in which innocent bystanders were injured by stray shots. This is why guns need to be controlled.
Daniel William McKnight

“Even well-meaning people who may wish to carry guns — we see guns stolen and heated arguments escalate in a hurry — and from our viewpoint, we would love for it to be the NYPD and law enforcement to be the ones carrying the guns.

“Let us deal with the criminals illegally carrying guns on the street, which is a tough enough job as it is these days, and not infuse extra guns on the streets of literally every neighborhood.”

Shea mentioned recent cases of innocent bystanders being hit by stray shots as reasons why guns should not be controlled. Shea cited the case of a 26-year old woman who was pushing her 2-year-old daughter in a stroller in Bronx Thursday night.

Paul Clement standing while speaking to the Supreme Court on November 3, 2021.
Paul Clement, standing while speaking before the Supreme Court on November 3, 2021.
Dana Verkouteren via AP

With murders nearly double the 2018 level and other major offenses, such as rape and felonious assault also soaring, Shea also railed against reducing jail populations through bail reform and suggested courts and lawmakers were consistently making cops’ jobs harder.

“When you look at some of the things that have come out recently, the bail being the most recent one, where you’re just letting the criminals go over and over,” he said.

“When’s the last time we had a law that actually helped the police passed in New York State?

“We’ve had our pulse on how to keep guns out of New York City for so long and to have that upended right now really is a concern.”

Katie Novotny displays a sign of protest during a demonstration at the U.S. Supreme Court.
Katie Novotny protests during a demonstration at U.S. Supreme Court.
REUTERS/Tom Brenner

The Supreme Court is not expected in the near future to rule on the concealed weapon case for many months.

More Long Island News

Releated

How to Manage a Child with Cerebral Palsy

Children with cerebral palsy have unique requirements. Although your child’s physicians and therapists manage much of their therapy, there are significant ways you can help make their life simpler. Cerebral palsy affects everyone differently, thus no two families have the same experience when it comes to their child’s care and treatment of cerebral palsy. Whether […]